High Court Blocks COFEK Withdrawal in US–Kenya Health Data Case
The High Court has just knocked back a bid by the Consumer Federation of Kenya (COFEK) to pull the plug on its petition to void the Sh208 billion US-Kenya health data sharing deal, which means this super important case is still very much on the table.
In a decision that will have serious implications for the case ahead, Justice Nyaundi sided with an objection from the Katiba Institute – and it was a big win for them. The judge basically said courts have the final say on constitutional petitions that are filed in the public interest.
Why the Court Said No
It all comes down to a pretty simple idea that’s been gaining traction in recent years: public interest cases aren’t just about the people who file them – they’re about everyone.
Justice Nyaundi made it crystal clear that once a public interest petition hits the court, it’s no longer just about the people who filed it. The court can choose to intervene if it thinks that would protect some really important constitutional rights or the wider public interest. It’s not automatically a done deal – the court can step in and stop the petition from being withdrawn if that would be a bad idea.
The Katiba Institute had really dug in and opposed COFEK’s move to pull out of the case, arguing that this was too big an issue for just one group to decide – and it involves the rights of millions of Kenyans.
Omtatah Steps In as Case Moves Forward
Even as COFEK tried to bail out, the case is not going to go away anytime soon. Busia Senator Okiya Omtatah said he would keep on pushing forward with his own petition, which has been merged with COFEK’s. This sets the stage for a full-on hearing – and the court has given the go-ahead for that to happen in May 2026.
What’s at Stake in the Health Data Deal
At the heart of the petition is the Kenya-US Health Cooperation Framework. This is a massive multi-billion shilling deal that lets the two countries swap and share medical and epidemiological data.
Some people reckon that partnerships like this will really help with disease surveillance and make public health responses stronger. But others have their doubts.
Critics are worried about how this sensitive data will be handled, who has control of it and whether there are proper safeguards in place to keep personal info safe.
A Win for Public Interest Litigation?
Katiba Institute is pretty chuffed with the ruling – they say it shows how important public interest litigation is when it comes to holding institutions to account.
The decision sends a pretty clear message – cases that are about constitutional rights and the public good can’t just be shut down part way through, especially when there are still loads of questions hanging in the air.
And now – everyone is looking to the May hearing, where the court will start to unpick the really important legal and constitutional issues at the heart of this super contentious deal.
In Other News: Kenya Mobile Money Users Hit 51.4 Million as Digital Transfers Surge in 2025
High Court Blocks COFEK Withdrawal in US–Kenya Health Data Case
